What are agreed value policies?

Unlike standard insurance, where a vehicle’s payout might be based on its depreciated market value, agreed value policies allow the owner and insurer to determine the car’s worth upfront. This agreed amount could serve as the basis for compensation, avoiding disputes or shortfalls during a claim.

For instance, a fully restored 1970 Jaguar E-Type may hold significant value that far exceeds its book price. With an agreed value policy, the owner and insurer could settle on a figure that reflects its market demand, condition, and rarity.

You should always make sure that you speak to customer service people at the company you would like to buy a policy from and get the agreed price in writing. Their contact details are available after you have compared quotes but before you actually buy the policy.


Female driver near her damaged car, contacting her insurer to make a claim.
Feels great knowing I’ve got the right cover.

Why might classic car owners consider this type of cover?

Classic cars often differ from modern vehicles in that their value can appreciate over time. Components like originality, restoration quality, and historical significance might all influence a classic car’s worth. Standard policies may not account for these factors, potentially leading to insufficient payouts in the event of a total loss.

  • Rare models with limited production runs
  • Vehicles with bespoke restorations
  • Cars maintained in concours condition

By agreeing on a value, owners might ensure that their investment is fully recognised and compensated appropriately.

How might agreed value policies work?

The process of obtaining this type of policy typically involves an evaluation to determine the vehicle’s worth. This might include submitting photographs, restoration receipts, and independent appraisals. Once the value is agreed upon, it remains fixed for the duration of the policy, subject to periodic reassessment.

For example, a 1965 Mini Cooper S with extensive restoration might require detailed documentation of parts and labour to establish its agreed value. Regular updates could ensure the policy remains reflective of market conditions and any further work carried out.

Are there limitations to consider?

Whilst these policies might provide significant benefits, they can come with conditions and exclusions. Owners might need to consider the following:

  • Storage requirements, such as garaging the vehicle
  • Usage restrictions, including mileage caps
  • Exclusions for modifications that haven’t been declared

Who might benefit most from this type of cover?

Agreed value policies might appeal to a wide range of classic car owners, from collectors to weekend enthusiasts. Drivers who frequently showcase their vehicles at events, for example, could find this cover particularly relevant. Similarly, those who have invested heavily in bespoke restorations may appreciate the certainty it offers.

A collector with a 1950s Aston Martin might find it non-negotiable to document every aspect of the car’s provenance and condition to secure an accurate valuation. The resulting policy could reflect the car’s rarity and ensure appropriate compensation if an accident occurred during transit or an event.

How might this cover differ for vintage vehicles?

Vintage cars, often older and rarer than more recent classics, might require even more tailored policies. Their value might be tied not only to condition but also to historical significance and originality. Agreed value policies could help preserve this tailored worth.

For instance, a pre-war Rolls-Royce might require expert appraisal to establish its true market value. An agreed value policy could then provide clarity and protection, avoiding the pitfalls of undervaluation.

What factors influence the agreed value?

Determining the value of a classic car can be a contrasting process. Factors that might be considered include:

  • Restoration quality and originality
  • Market trends for similar vehicles
  • Provenance, including ownership history

Regular reassessments might also be advisable, particularly if the car’s value appreciates or significant work is undertaken.

How might agreed value policies affect premiums?

Whilst these policies might come with higher premiums than standard cover, the benefits could outweigh the costs for many classic car owners. The certainty of knowing your vehicle is covered for its true worth might provide valuable a sense of stability.

For example, an owner of a Triumph TR6 might compare the additional cost of an agreed value policy with the potential shortfall in payout under standard cover. The reassurance of knowing they’d be compensated fairly could make the added expense worthwhilst .

What alternatives might exist?

For owners who decide that agreed value policies aren’t suitable, other options might include:

  • Market value policies, which base payouts on current market trends
  • Laid-up cover for vehicles not currently being driven
  • Policies tailored to specific usage, such as shows or limited-mileage driving

Exploring these alternatives could help drivers find a solution that fits their circumstances.


Man leaning on a damaged hatchback, calling his car insurer to make a claim.
All set up - so easy and exactly what I was after.

How can classic car owners find the right policy?

Comparing policies and providers is an important step in checking around for cover that meets the needs of your vehicle. Speaking with specialists who understand classic cars might be particularly helpful, as they could offer tailored advice and options.

For instance, a provider with experience in insuring classic British cars might offer insights into the subdivisions of covering models like the Lotus Elan or the MG MGB. Their expertise could simplify the process and ensure the policy aligns with the vehicle’s value and usage.

Are agreed value policies worth considering?

For many classic car owners, the certainty these policies offer might be invaluable. By ensuring that your vehicle’s true worth is recognised, they could provide a level of protection not available with standard cover. However, whether they’re suitable could depend on your vehicle, its usage, and your individual priorities.

Take the next step

If you’re considering agreed value policies for your classic car, comparing options could help you find cover tailor-fitted to match your requirements. Examine your choices today to ensure your vehicle is valued and protected appropriately.